The Mid-Year Review: A Complete Guide for Managers and Teams

A mid-year review is a one-on-one check-in held halfway through the year to assess progress, realign goals, and keep employees engaged. This guide offers practical examples and templates to help managers and HR teams lead effective, growth-focused conversations.

What is a Mid-Year Review?

A mid-year review is a structured performance review conversation that you, as a manager, schedule every six months with your employees. Such reviews are essential for reviewing their performances, discussing their progress, and defining their individual and team goals. 

It's an opportunity to: 

• Reflect on progress 
• Refine goals 
• Address blockers 
• Re-engage the team

Mid-year performance reviews are different from annual reviews. These focus on ongoing processes and projects alongside future goals while ensuring continued improvement. On the contrary, yearly reviews are more of final evaluations conducted at year-end to assess your employee's year-round performance. 

Goals and Benefits of a Mid-Year Review

Mid-year performance review examples are critical components of your performance assessment processes. Such reviews track performance progress, provide feedback, and foster continued improvement. They are also essential for assessing the alignment of individual and team performance goals and objectives with organizational goals. 

For the Organization

• Realign employees with strategic priorities.
• Identify early signs of disengagement or misalignment.
• Make room for course correction and coaching.

For Managers

• Strengthen team relationships.
• Refocus teams around changing goals.
• Catch performance concerns before they escalate.

For Employees

• Understand how their contributions are perceived.
• Get clarity on expectations for the second half of the year.
• Reconfirm their role in the team's direction.

{{cta-1}}

Mid-Year Review Process: Step-by-Step

This halfway check-in process helps you assess your team members' progress towards their goals. It is also beneficial in identifying areas for improvement and defining new objectives for the remaining six months. 

Step 1: Preparation

Step 1 of your mid-year review template is preparation. Start by setting clear expectations for each of your employees. Schedule meetings, prepare an agenda, review their past performances and ask your employees to self-reflect. Here are two key highlights of this step:

• The manager and employee review goals, metrics, and feedback so far.
• Pull data from performance tools, 1:1 notes, and peer feedback.

Step 2: Self-Assessment

Step 2 in the list of how to write a mid-year review involves asking employees to self-assess themselves. This assessment involves reflecting on their achievements, identifying improvement areas, seeking feedback, and aligning their individual goals with the team and the organization. Here are two key highlights of step 2 from the best mid-year review examples:

• Encourage employees to submit a mid-year self-review in advance.
• Reflect on wins, challenges, learning, and aspirations.

Step 3: The Review Conversation

A successful mid-year review conversation includes giving employees a fair chance to ask mid-year review questions. There are several questions to ask during a mid-year review as a manager regarding your employees' past performance, career aspirations, setting goals and defining their action plans. Here are two key highlights of this section:

• Hold a structured conversation around performance, engagement, goals, and growth.
• Ask open-ended questions, listen deeply, and challenge supportively.

Step 4: Documentation and Follow-Up

Step 4 in your mid-year review template should include the stages of documentation and follow-ups. Summarize your performance review discussion, including achievements, actionable plans, and key takeaways. Share this summary with the concerned employee and schedule regular follow-up sessions. This is an essential stage of an effective mid-year performance review template for monitoring your employees' performance in the remaining half. The highlight of this step is:

• Use a simple mid-year review template to summarize feedback and action points.
• Share the following steps and set up goal checkpoints.

Mid-Year Review Examples

There are plenty of mid-year performance review examples you can refer to online before conducting your mid-year reviews. These examples are crucial for understanding how to frame a better mid-year performance review template. Here are some essential examples of mid-year reviews for your organizational employees, managers, and HRs. 

A. Mid-Year Review Examples for Employees

Here are some mid-year review examples for employees you can use during your performance review sessions with them: 

• "So far this year, your ability to lead cross-functional initiatives has been a highlight. For the remainder of the year, let's focus on mentoring junior team members."
• "You've exceeded expectations in client satisfaction scores. Next, I'd like you to build more proactive communication with internal stakeholders."

B. Mid-Year Review Examples for Underperformers

For underperforming employees, you should focus on specific improvement areas, offer constructive feedback, and collaboratively work on a creative improvement plan. Here are some mid-year performance review examples for underperformers: 

‍

• "You've shown flashes of potential, especially in customer handling. But missed deadlines and a lack of follow-through are holding you back. Let's work on time management together over the next quarter."
• "There's a need for more consistent communication from your side. I suggest weekly check-ins and goal alignment sessions for 30 days."

C. Mid-Year Review Examples for High Performers

Your high-performing employees are your star performers, skyrocketing your team's success. 

Choose mid-year performance review examples focusing on recognizing their achievements, acknowledging their strengths and attitude, and setting actionable yet realistic goals for them. Here are some good examples of year reviews: 

• "You've played a critical role in delivering results this quarter. I want to start preparing you for a leadership opportunity."
• "You've grown in autonomy and impact. What stretch projects would challenge you in the second half of the year?"

Mid-Year Review Questions for Managers and Employees

A productive mid-year performance review should focus on using your employees' accomplishments. Assess their progress towards their pre-defined goals, enlist their improvement areas, and future development. Here are some quick tips for setting the best mid-year performance review objectives examples: 

Questions Managers Should Ask

Fostering a positive and productive working environment requires open communication while addressing the needs of your employees. Scheduling such healthy conversations involves setting priorities and discussing career aspirations and challenges. Your mid-year performance review template should include questions such as: 

• What are you most proud of achieving in the past 6 months?
• What blockers are you facing that I may not be aware of?
• What goals excite you most for the second half of the year?

Questions Employees Should Ask

Fostering a productive working culture is not just a manager's job but that of the employees, too. As a manager, you should be good at anticipating what is coming from your employees in such conversations. Here are some mid-year review questions to ask managers they might ask you: 

• Where do you think I can improve or add more value?
• How do you see my role evolving in the coming months?
• Is there an opportunity to take on more responsibility?

Mid-Year Performance Review Objectives Examples

A mid-year performance review objectives example should focus on two critical aspects of your employees' past performance and future goals. Here are some of the best ones used so far:

• "Increase team OKR alignment score by 20% by the end of Q4."
• "Close 3 enterprise deals with an average sales cycle of under 90 days."
• "Mentor 2 junior developers and complete at least four peer code reviews per sprint."
• "Deliver a customer success webinar series and improve NPS by 10 points."

Tips for a Successful Mid-Year Review

Here are some quick yet helpful mid-year performance review tips for employees for your upcoming review:

• Focus on the future, not just the past.
• Be specific, not vague—vague feedback is unhelpful.
• Let the employee speak more than you do.
• Avoid surprises—feedback should never feel new.
• Make it a habit, not a once-a-year event.

Free Mid-Year Review Template

There are several free mid-year review templates available online that you can use to structure your next performance review. Use the tips below to create your own template and the above-mentioned mid-year performance review samples for a structured performance review.  

• Create a customizable template to document:
  
  • Goals review
  • Highlights and wins
  • Areas of development
  • New goals and support needs
• Include a version for employees and managers.

{{cta-2}}